Shein and Temu: Transforming Fast Fashion and E-Commerce Landscape

Table of Contents

Shein and Temu: Transforming Fast Fashion and E-Commerce Landscape

As Shein and Temu continue to gain traction, their disruptive impact on the U.S. e-commerce and fast-fashion sectors has sparked discussions around exploitative labor practices, tariff avoidance, and extensive data collection. These concerns arise in an environment marked by growing anti-China sentiments.

BTIG, a financial services firm, delves into an in-depth analysis of these two businesses. By closely examining the surge in fast fashion and the rise of online marketplaces, BTIG sheds light on the meteoric growth experienced by Shein and Temu. Additionally, the report identifies U.S. companies that may be particularly vulnerable to the rapid ascent of these two players in the industry.

Shein

In the dynamic landscape of e-commerce, Shein and Temu have emerged as formidable players. Shein, with a staggering $45 billion in gross merchandise value (GMV), outpaces Temu’s $14 billion GMV. Together, they have generated a whopping $25 billion GMV in the U.S. market alone, and their trajectory points toward an impressive $40 billion annually—twice the revenue of retail giants like Macy’s (M) or Ross (ROST).

What fuels this meteoric rise? BTIG attributes it to a combination of factors. First, both companies defy traditional e-commerce norms, subverting established models. Second, their ultra-low pricing strategies have catapulted them to rapid market share gains, even amidst inflationary pressures. Third, they impact legacy U.S. brands not only in market dominance but also by driving up advertising costs in an increasingly competitive arena. Lastly, Shein and Temu deftly exploit U.S. de minimis duty rules, securing tariff exemptions on overseas packages valued under $800—an astute move that saves them millions in tariffs.

As these disruptors continue to reshape the industry, businesses must adapt to their innovative approaches and stay vigilant in an ever-evolving landscape.

Who stands the most the most to lose from the encroachment of Shein?

BTIG’s analysis reveals that Shein shares approximately 20% overlap with Revolve (RVLV) and Lulu’s Fashion Lounge (LVLU). However, the intersection is significantly more pronounced when it comes to established retailers like H&M, Forever 21, and Zara.

As the fast-fashion industry continues to evolve, understanding these dynamics becomes crucial for businesses aiming to thrive in this competitive landscape.

Temu has swiftly ascended to become one of the largest e-commerce players in the United States. Acting as a crucial intermediary between Chinese sellers and American consumers, Temu’s success hinges on its ability to source deeply discounted products directly from China. Much like Shein, Temu leverages favorable U.S./China trade policies and de minimis duty rules to its advantage.

The company strategically markets itself through social media platforms, with TikTok serving as a primary channel. By collaborating with influencers, Temu effectively captures the attention of a youthful demographic. Additionally, the company invests heavily in advertising across Meta (META) and Google (GOOG). Notably, Temu employs gamification techniques in its ads, successfully engaging a larger proportion of younger shoppers.

While precise figures remain elusive, BTIG estimates that Temu garnered an impressive 50 million to 120 million active U.S. users within its first year of operation. Even more remarkable is Temu’s customer retention rate: over 28% of Temu’s customers make repeat transactions 16 months after their initial purchase. This retention rate nearly doubles that of retail giants Target (TGT) and Walmart (WMT), and significantly surpasses Etsy (ETSY) and Five Below (FIVE), although it remains below Amazon’s (NASDAQ:AMZN) formidable 50% retention.

As Temu continues its upward trajectory, businesses must closely monitor its innovative strategies and adapt to the evolving e-commerce landscape.

“Challenges Ahead for Shein and Temu: Navigating Disruptions and Sustainability”

While the rapid rise of Shein and Temu suggests exponential growth, several potential challenges loom on the horizon for these e-commerce giants.

Supply Chain Vulnerability: Shein and Temu heavily rely on manufacturing from China. However, the strained relationship between the U.S. and China poses a risk to their fragile supply chains. Any further deterioration could disrupt their operations significantly.
U.S. Legislation and Human Rights Concerns: Both companies face scrutiny over alleged use of forced labor and cotton harvested from exploited Uyghurs in Xinjiang. The U.S. has responded by banning imports from the region. Compliance with human rights standards is crucial for their continued success.
Intellectual Property Challenges: Shein has faced accusations of intellectual property infringement due to selling clothing designs from other brands. As intellectual property laws tighten, Shein may need to pivot toward original designs, potentially impacting profits.
TikTok Data Controversy: The recent spotlight on TikTok’s data practices affects both Shein and Temu. The latter collects substantial data on U.S. customers. A potential TikTok ban could reverberate across other Chinese companies, leaving them vulnerable to U.S. enforcement actions.
Sustainability Awareness: Customers are increasingly conscious of sustainability. Shein’s reliance on non-recyclable materials has drawn scrutiny. While cost remains a priority, studies indicate that 47% of respondents aged 25-49 are willing to pay more for sustainable products.

As these challenges unfold, Shein and Temu must adapt swiftly to maintain their competitive edge in the ever-evolving e-commerce landscape.

fast fashion